Ghostwritten is David Mitchell’s debut novel. I’ve previously read and loved Cloud Atlas and The Thousand Autumns of Jacob de Zoet, and Black Swan Green wasn’t bad either. I’m pretty impressed by this one, too.
As in both Cloud Atlas and TTAoJdZ, the structure of the story plays an important role. It’s a mosaic of a book: a novel, and at the same time a collection of 9 short stories (plus an epilogue). Each story stands on its own, but they are also all linked to each other by some minor event or character, and together they make up a larger story. At the very end we are confronted with major events that would never have occurred if the preceding chain of chance meetings had been broken at some point. It’s a kind of “butterfly flaps its wings in Siberia, causes hurricane in Gulf of Mexico” idea: everything is interconnected and small events can have a large effect.
And just like in those two books, this one employs wildly differing people, genres and voices for the different parts: from an old lady tending to a tea-shop on a holy mountain in China, to a courtesan-turned-art thief in St. Petersburg. That last one, the story in St. Petersburg, kept jarring me with names and behaviour that were not quite right for a Russian, and a US reviewer had a similar issue with the New York story. Perhaps Mitchell was a bit too ambitious when trying to cover everything from Irish islands to Mongolia. But luckily I am far less familiar than he is with all the other places, except London, so I had no such problems with the rest of the book.
The ending itself was a bit clichéd, and the next to last chapter (on a small island off the Irish coast) too full of pseudoscientific talk about quantum uncertainty and amateur philosophy.
It is nevertheless a very good book, though slightly weaker than Cloud Atlas, which it most closely resembles. One advantage of this mosaic setup is that I can remember the best stories for their own merits, without contamination from the shortcomings of the weaker ones.
I suppose Mitchell had this idea of small stories making up a larger one and is now trying to perfect it in subsequent books, approaching it from various angles. This is his first attempt, and he only gets better with practice.


