
For years, we had the perfect lemon press. Stable, good grip, efficient at pressing, easy to pour. Tilted top surface, large drainage openings. Separate tops for lemons and oranges, one small, one larger. Perfect in all ways – except it was made of plastic and started cracking due to all the pressure we’ve put on it.
It’s from our time in London and we probably had it for years before moving, so it gave us a good twenty years of freshly pressed lemon juice. But its days are numbered so it was time to look for a new one.
Two years later, I have trialled some decent ones. Each of them is an improvement over the OG lemon press in some ways, but falls short in others.
This single-piece one in green melamine is nice and pointy on the top, very stable, super easy to clean. But: the side ridges are barely there, so you’re pressing the lemon against a mostlyl flat surface by brute force instead of scraping it open with the ridges.

This metal press from Exxent has better ridges, and is probably more or less unbreakable. But the top is a bit too rounded which makes it a bit harder to start pressing, and the holes are just a bit too small so they clog up and the juice all sits on top instead of draining into the lower part. Still, it’s the one that stays in use for now.

Does the ultimate lemon press exist? One that combines the best of both of these? I have email notifications set up on Tradera but haven’t found anything better than what we have. People sell flimsy plastic stuff, or the long-legged Alessi press that is more sculpture than utensil, or bird-shaped squeezers that also look more decorative than useful. And vintage glass lemon presses from the 1950s that look like they would be hard to clean, but who knows, maybe they’re not? Why is this so hard.