The “Chalion books” or the “World of the Five Gods” novels are three. The Curse of Chalion, Paladin of Souls, and The Hallowed Hunt.
The first one, The Curse of Chalion, was fabulous. This was one of the best fantasy books I’ve read, and so well worth all its awards.
The back cover on my edition, with its mentions of “traitorous intrigue” and “darkest, most forbidden magics” and “lethal maze of demonic paradox” gives an entirely incorrect picture of the mood in the book. It sounds like a wild, lurid tale full of shocking acts of magic – which is about as wrong as it can be. This is a thoughtful, beautiful, intelligent book.
Technically the description is correct. Those demons and magics and intrigues are there, and they make for an interesting plot, with some clever solutions to thorny problems. But the plot is not what I will remember the book for.
The most interesting part was the role that religion plays in the story. The book is a work of fantastical theological speculation almost as much as it is a story of adventure. What if gods were real and actively involved in the world? What powers might they have, and what limitations? What shape might divine intervention take? What might a saint be like, or a saviour?
The story follows one main character on his journey, both internal and external. I was rather annoyed with Cazaril at first. Nerveless, hopeless, weak, reduced to begging, nearly whining. I remember thinking – do I really want to read about this broken man for hundreds of pages? But then I came to understand him, and he started growing, and by the end I loved him. (As we are quite clearly meant to.) There are plenty of other interesting characters as well, many of them pleasingly intelligent. Only the bad guys were too obviously set up to only be bad guys and lacking in depth.
And all of this is told in beautiful language. Always flowing smoothly, always just right, never awkward. Plenty of sentences and phrases to savour, to read again just for the pleasure of it.
The second one, Paladin of Souls, explores similar themes of religion and personal growth to some extent. A forty-year-old madwoman, widow, murderer, decides to take a second chance at life. She rides off on a vacation, calling it a pilgrimage to make it seem more comme il faut for a noble lady. The gods get involved, and she is put in service of the gods regardless of her intents.
The starting point of the story is interesting, but I found the book as a whole weaker than the first one in both plotting, character-building, and exploration of its themes. The first book was small and personal in scale but grand in spirit and ambition. This one was enjoyable, and Bujold’s writing is masterful as ever, but the book was somewhat predictable in plotting, and more lightweight and conventional than I had hoped for.
The third book, The Hallowed Hunt, was a disappointment. There was none of the depth of the earlier books: neither depth of theme nor depth of emotion. Instead this was even more of a mystery story than the second one. Every chapter uncovered more facts and added more complications. So many plot twists!
The main character was surprisingly, almost annoyingly passive and uninteresting. I don’t think he ever had an interesting thought. Or even took any interesting action – things happened to him instead.
And the book has a “love at first sight” romance which really stuck in my craw. The couple are proclaim everlasting love and are ready to marry after knowing each other for barely a few weeks, which they have mostly spent apart from each other. But their souls are connected, or something. Ew.
I’m very glad I read the books in this order, because if I had started with The Hallowed Hunt then I am quite sure I wouldn’t have been interested in the others. And what a loss that would have been!